Pick a bearing by its load direction first: deep groove ball and cylindrical roller bearings for radial load, tapered roller and angular contact ball bearings for combined radial and axial load, and thrust bearings for axial load. Roller bearings carry heavier loads than same-size ball bearings; ball bearings run with less friction (SKF). Then check misalignment: rigid bearings accept only minutes of arc (a deep groove ball bearing 2 to 10), while self-aligning ball and spherical roller bearings accept 1.5° to 3.5°. The ratings below are Timken's and SKF's own published comparisons, with numbers from SKF's Rolling bearings catalogue. To work out the shaft torque a bearing supports, use the Torque Calculator.
Load capability by bearing type (Timken)
| Bearing type | Pure radial load | Pure axial load | Combined load | Moment load |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Radial (deep groove) ball | Good | Fair | Good | Fair |
| Angular contact ball | Fair | Good | Excellent | Good |
| Cylindrical roller | Excellent | Unsuitable | Fair | Unsuitable |
| Tapered roller | Good | Good | Excellent | Excellent |
| Spherical roller | Good | Fair | Good | Unsuitable |
| Thrust ball | Poor | Excellent | Poor | Poor |
| Thrust cylindrical roller | Unsuitable | Good | Unsuitable | Unsuitable |
| Thrust tapered roller | Unsuitable | Excellent | Poor | Poor |
| Thrust spherical roller | Unsuitable | Excellent | Fair | Unsuitable |
Speed, friction, stiffness and mounting (Timken)
| Bearing type | Speed | Low friction | High stiffness | Misalignment | Locating (fixed) | Non-locating (floating) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Radial (deep groove) ball | Excellent | Excellent | Fair | Good | Good | Good |
| Angular contact ball | Excellent | Good | Good | Poor | Good | Good |
| Cylindrical roller | Excellent | Excellent | Good | Poor | Fair | Excellent |
| Tapered roller | Good | Good | Excellent | Poor | Excellent | Good |
| Spherical roller | Fair | Fair | Good | Excellent | Good | Good |
| Thrust ball | Excellent | Good | Good | Poor | Excellent | Unsuitable |
| Thrust cylindrical roller | Poor | Poor | Excellent | Unsuitable | Fair | Unsuitable |
| Thrust tapered roller | Good | Good | Excellent | Poor | Good | Unsuitable |
| Thrust spherical roller | Fair | Fair | Good | Excellent | Good | Unsuitable |
Reading the ratings
- Both tables are Timken's Table 1, Relative operating characteristics of various bearing types, transcribed word for word. They compare types in general; a particular size, series, cage or lubricant can do better or worse.
- Needle roller and CARB toroidal bearings are not in Timken's table. SKF rates needle roller bearings with steel rings good (++) for radial load and unsuitable for axial and moment load, for "very limited radial space"; their low cross-section and many rollers give a high load capacity. CARB toroidal roller bearings are rated excellent for radial load, unsuitable for axial load and good for misalignment; they work as the non-locating bearing.
- Where SKF and Timken differ: Timken rates the thrust ball bearing "Excellent" for speed, but SKF's selection rules say thrust bearings "cannot accommodate speeds as high as same-sized radial bearings". Treat thrust-bearing speed as limited and check the maker's speed rating.
- SKF's general rules: ball bearings have lower friction than same-size roller bearings; single-row bearings run cooler than double- or multi-row ones; hybrid bearings with ceramic rolling elements take higher speeds than all-steel ones; stiffness is higher for roller and full-complement bearings and can be raised by preload.
Permissible misalignment (SKF guideline values)
| Bearing type | Permissible misalignment (angle) | Equivalent (degrees) |
|---|---|---|
| Deep groove ball, single | 2 to 10 minutes of arc | 0.03° to 0.17° |
| Angular contact ball, matched pair | back-to-back 2, face-to-face 4 minutes of arc | 0.03° / 0.07° |
| Self-aligning ball | 1.5° to 3° (sealed 2RS1 types 1.5°) | 1.5° to 3° |
| Cylindrical roller | 3 to 4 minutes of arc (by series) | 0.05° to 0.07° |
| Needle roller, machined rings | 1 minute of arc | 0.02° |
| Alignment needle roller | 3° static, no dynamic misalignment | 3° |
| Tapered roller (SKF Explorer) | 2 to 4 minutes of arc | 0.03° to 0.07° |
| Spherical roller | 1.5° to 3.5° (by series and size) | 1.5° to 3.5° |
| CARB toroidal roller | 0.5° | 0.5° |
| Thrust ball | none (sphered housing washer: initial misalignment only) | 0° |
| Cylindrical and needle roller thrust | none | 0° |
| Spherical roller thrust | 0.3° to 3° (falls as load rises) | 0.3° to 3° |
Notes on misalignment
- SKF: "Misalignment increases bearing noise and reduces bearing service life", and rigid bearings (deep groove, angular contact, cylindrical, needle and tapered roller) only take it within their internal clearance.
- Spherical roller bearings: SKF's values (series 213 2°, 222 1.5-2°, 223 3°, 232 up to 3.5°, 238 and 239 1.5°) assume light to normal load (P ≤ 0.1 C) and misalignment fixed relative to the outer ring; if it moves around, only a few tenths of a degree are allowed.
- Spherical roller thrust bearings: SKF allows up to 2-3° under light load (P0 < 0.05 C0) falling to 0.3° above 0.3 C0 for rotating shafts; Timken quotes a maximum of ±2.5° for its TSR type. Use the bearing maker's figure.
- Minutes of arc are converted to degrees on this page (60 minutes = 1°).
Where the makers use each type
| Deep groove ball | The common choice for light to moderate axial load with radial load (SKF). With a snap ring in the outer ring, used in automobile transmissions and wherever housing shoulders are costly to machine (Timken). |
|---|---|
| Angular contact ball | Gear reducers, pumps, worm drives, vertical shafts and machine-tool spindles, often in matched pairs (Timken). Carries thrust mainly in one direction. |
| Cylindrical roller | Heavy radial load. NU and N types let the shaft expand axially with minimal friction, so they suit the non-locating (floating) position; NJ, NF, NUP and NP types with ribs take light thrust (Timken). |
| Tapered roller | Combined and moment loads. The single-row type is normally fitted as one of an opposed pair and set to the required end-play or preload; double-row TDO types are chosen where overturning moments are significant (Timken). |
| Spherical roller | Heavy loads with misalignment or shaft deflection; makers offer variants for vibratory applications (Timken W800, SKF) and wind energy (SKF). |
| Needle roller | Very limited radial space, where a compact low cross-section bearing is needed (SKF). |
| CARB toroidal roller | Non-locating position that must also accept misalignment, paired with a spherical roller or self-aligning ball bearing (SKF). |
| Thrust ball | Lighter axial loads at higher speeds than roller thrust bearings; angular-contact thrust types on vertical shafts such as oil-field rotary tables and machine-tool indexing tables. Should always run under axial load (Timken). |
| Thrust cylindrical roller | Heavy axial loads at moderate speeds; standard types to an outer-ring surface speed of 3,000 ft/min (15 m/s); needs square shaft and housing seats (Timken). |
| Thrust tapered roller | Crane hooks (extreme thrust and shock), steering pivots, rolling-mill screwdowns, extruders and cone crushers (Timken). |
| Thrust spherical roller | Axial plus radial load with self-alignment: air regenerators, centrifugal pumps and deep-well pumps (Timken). |
Bearing life (ISO 281 basic rating life)
| L10 (million revolutions) | L10 = (C / P)p, the life that 90% of a large group of identical bearings reach or exceed. |
|---|---|
| L10h (hours) | L10h = 106 / (60 n) × L10 at a constant speed n (r/min). |
| C | Basic dynamic load rating (kN), from the bearing tables. |
| P | Equivalent dynamic bearing load (kN), combining radial and axial load. |
| p | 3 for ball bearings, 10/3 for roller bearings. |
| Worked example | Ball bearing with P = C / 5: L10 = 5³ = 125 million revolutions; at 1,500 r/min L10h = 106 / 90,000 × 125 ≈ 1,389 h. A roller bearing at the same ratio: 510/3 ≈ 214 million revolutions (calculated on this page). |
| SKF rating life | Lnm = a1 × aSKF × L10 adds reliability (a1) and lubrication, contamination and fatigue-load-limit effects (aSKF), following the ISO 281 approach. Real service life can differ a lot from L10. |
Typical design life by machine (SKF guideline values)
| Machine type | Specification life (operating hours) |
|---|---|
| Household machines, agricultural machines, instruments, medical equipment | 300 to 3,000 |
| Short or intermittent use: electric hand tools, workshop lifting tackle, construction machines | 3,000 to 8,000 |
| Short or intermittent use needing high reliability: lifts (elevators), cranes for packaged goods | 8,000 to 12,000 |
| 8 hours a day, not fully used: general gear drives, industrial electric motors, rotary crushers | 10,000 to 25,000 |
| 8 hours a day, fully used: machine tools, woodworking machines, conveyor belts, fans, printing equipment, centrifuges | 20,000 to 30,000 |
| Continuous 24-hour use: rolling-mill gear units, medium electrical machinery, compressors, mine hoists, pumps, textile machinery | 40,000 to 50,000 |
| Wind turbines: main shaft, yaw, pitch, gearbox and generator bearings | 30,000 to 100,000 |
| Water works, rotary furnaces, cable stranding, ocean-going ship propulsion | 60,000 to 100,000 |
| Large electric machines, power plant, mine pumps and fans, ship tunnel-shaft bearings | 100,000 to 200,000 |
Corrections to the previous version
- The old table's ticks and speed words had no source. Replaced with Timken's published ratings. Changes include: cylindrical roller thrust capacity "Low" → Unsuitable for pure axial load; angular contact pure radial "✓" → Fair; spherical roller speed "Low" → Fair; thrust ball speed "Medium" → Excellent (Timken; SKF disagrees, see above); deep groove axial "Moderate" → Fair.
- Removed as unsourced: the "magnetic", "ceramic hybrid (ultra-high RPM)" and "plain / sleeve bushing" rows (plain bearings are not rolling bearings; SKF's only statement on hybrids, that they run faster than all-steel bearings, is kept in the notes), the example uses "fans, motors, skateboards", "car wheel hubs", "gearbox or U-joint", "crane slew bearings", and the selection tip about sealed stainless for food and medical use.
- Kept and sourced: the L10 life formula (now with the 90% reliability definition and units from SKF / ISO 281). Added: permissible misalignment in numbers, needle and CARB bearings, typical design lives.
Sources
- The Timken Company, Timken Engineering Manual, order no. 10424, 2017 (timken.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Timken-Engineering-Manual_10424.pdf). Used for: Table 1 relative operating characteristics, and bearing-type descriptions and applications (pp. 10-27).
- SKF Group, Rolling bearings, PUB BU/P1 17000/1 EN, October 2018 (skf.com/binaries/pub12/…/Rolling-bearings---17000_1-EN). Used for: selection criteria and suitability chart (B.2, pp. 72-82), basic rating life and specification-life table (B.3, pp. 88-89), permissible misalignment from each product section's bearing-data table.
- ISO 281 (dynamic load ratings and rating life) is sold by ISO; the formula here is as published in the SKF catalogue.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between ball and roller bearings?
Roller bearings carry heavier loads than ball bearings of the same size and are stiffer, while ball bearings have lower friction and suit higher speeds (SKF). Timken rates a cylindrical roller bearing "Excellent" for pure radial load against "Good" for a radial (deep groove) ball bearing, and both "Excellent" for speed.
Which bearing should I use for combined radial and axial load?
A tapered roller bearing or an angular contact ball bearing; Timken rates both "Excellent" for combined load. A deep groove ball bearing handles light to moderate axial load as well (SKF). The larger the contact angle, the more axial load a bearing takes; ISO treats bearings with contact angles up to 45° as radial and the rest as thrust bearings. Tapered and angular contact bearings are normally used in opposed pairs.
Which bearings tolerate misalignment?
Self-aligning ones. SKF gives 1.5° to 3° for self-aligning ball bearings, 1.5° to 3.5° for spherical roller bearings and 0.5° for CARB toroidal roller bearings, depending on series. Rigid bearings accept only minutes of arc: 2 to 10 for a deep groove ball bearing, 2 to 4 for tapered roller and 3 to 4 for cylindrical roller bearings. Thrust ball and cylindrical roller thrust bearings cannot tolerate any.
Can a thrust bearing take radial load?
A thrust ball or cylindrical roller thrust bearing cannot: Timken rates them "Unsuitable" for pure radial load. A spherical roller thrust bearing is the exception; it takes axial load plus some radial load and self-aligns (Timken quotes ±2.5°; SKF 0.3° to 3° depending on series and load).
How do you calculate bearing life?
The ISO 281 basic rating life is L10 = (C / P)^p million revolutions, where C is the dynamic load rating, P the equivalent load, and p = 3 for ball bearings or 10/3 for roller bearings. In hours, L10h = 10^6 / (60 n) × L10 at n r/min. L10 is the life that 90% of identical bearings reach. A ball bearing loaded to one fifth of C lasts 125 million revolutions, about 1,390 hours at 1,500 r/min.