Electronics

MOSFET vs IGBT Comparison

MOSFET and IGBT power transistors compared — voltage, switching speed, losses, and sweet spot.

Side-by-side

AspectMOSFETIGBT
StructureVoltage-controlled FETFET gate drives BJT output
V_drive10–15 V gate (standard)15–20 V gate
On-state dropR_DS(on) · I (low at low V, rises with V)V_CE(sat) ≈ 1–2 V (roughly constant)
Switching speedFastest (ns)Slower (100 ns – µs) — has tail current
Typical V rating20–1 000 V600–6 500 V
Typical I rating0.1 A – 400 A5 A – 3 000 A
Switching lossesLow (square turn-off)Higher (tail current at turn-off)
Conduction lossesLow at low current / VLow at high current / V
Temp coefficientPositive (parallels well)Negative at low I — parallel with caution

Rule of thumb

< 250 VMOSFET — lower R_DS(on), faster
250–600 VModern Si or SiC MOSFETs take over traditional IGBT territory
> 600 V, high powerIGBT — lower conduction loss at high V/I
> 20 kHz switchingMOSFET (Si or SiC) — IGBT tail current dominates
Motor drives (kW)IGBT common; SiC MOSFETs displacing at higher efficiency

Worked example: conduction crossover

A MOSFET acts as a resistor and an IGBT acts roughly as a fixed voltage drop, so there is a current below which the MOSFET wastes less power and above which the IGBT does. Take a MOSFET with 50 milliohms RDS(on) (hot) and an IGBT with VCE(sat) of 1.8 V.

At 20 A the MOSFET dissipates I²R = 400 × 0.05 = 20 W while the IGBT dissipates 1.8 × 20 = 36 W, so the MOSFET wins. At 100 A the MOSFET dissipates 10,000 × 0.05 = 500 W while the IGBT dissipates about 180 W, so the IGBT wins. The crossover is where the two are equal, I = VCE(sat) / RDS(on) = 1.8 / 0.05 = 36 A. A high-voltage MOSFET has much higher RDS(on) than a low-voltage one, so the crossover moves lower as the voltage rating rises, which is why IGBTs take over at 600 V and above.

Switching loss: a rough estimate for each hard-switched transition is ½ × V × I × tcrossover. For 400 V and 20 A with a combined rise and fall of 100 ns, the energy per cycle is 0.5 × 400 × 20 × 100×10-9 = 0.4 mJ, which at 50 kHz is 20 W. IGBT tail current lengthens the turn-off time, which is why the same arithmetic gives much worse results at high frequency.

Design points

  • Freewheeling diode: an IGBT has no useful body diode, so inductive-load circuits use IGBT modules with an antiparallel diode. A MOSFET body diode works but is slow in hard-switched bridges; use a fast-recovery or SiC device in the half-bridge.
  • Gate drive: IGBTs usually turn on at 15 V and turn off with 0 V or a negative gate voltage to avoid false turn-on. Logic-level MOSFETs can be driven directly at 5 V, but only if the datasheet lists RDS(on) at that gate voltage.
  • Short-circuit ruggedness: IGBTs are rated for a short-circuit withstand time (often around 5 to 10 microseconds) that gate drivers detect with desaturation protection.

Notes

  • SiC (silicon carbide) and GaN (gallium nitride) MOSFETs extend the MOSFET sweet spot to higher voltage and frequency.
  • IGBTs have a tail current at turn-off — keep switching frequency below ~20 kHz to limit loss.
Was this article helpful?