Pension Calculator: Lump Sum or Annuity

Work out a defined-benefit pension from the plan formula, then value it. See the monthly pension, what the payments are worth today at a discount rate, with or without a cost-of-living adjustment, and the break-even age against a lump-sum offer.

Calculator Finance Updated Oct 4, 2026
Learn how this works
How to Use
  1. Enter your years of service, final average salary and the plan’s multiplier (often between 1.5% and 2.5% a year; your plan document gives the exact figure).
  2. Enter the age the pension starts and the age to value it to, such as your life expectancy or a cautious 90.
  3. Enter the yearly cost-of-living adjustment (COLA), or 0 if the pension is fixed, and a discount rate: what you think you could earn investing the money yourself.
  4. If your plan offers a lump sum, enter it to compare. Leave it blank to see the pension’s share of your salary instead.
  5. Read the monthly pension, its value at retirement and the break-even age, then follow the two lines on the chart.
Your Pension
years
$ / yr
% / yr
age
age
% / yr
%
$
Presets
Pension vs Lump Sum by Age
Monthly pension
—
Value of the pension
—
Pension worth more by
—
Break-even age
—

Worked Example

The pension. After 30 years with a final average salary of $80,000 and a 2% multiplier, the pension is 2% × 30 × $80,000 = $48,000 a year, $4,000 a month, from 62. A 2% COLA raises it each year, to $81,931 by 89.

What it is worth. Discounting each year of payments at 5% back to 62 and adding them up to age 90 gives $909,604. The plan offers $750,000 instead, $159,604 less. Invested at 5% and paying yourself the same rising income, the $750,000 runs out at 83 years 2 months: if you live longer, the pension wins.

The common mistake: adding up the payments without discounting. 28 years of a rising $48,000 pension totals $1,778,458, which makes any lump sum look poor, and simply counting until the payments reach $750,000 says you are paid back by 75 years 9 months. Money received later is worth less than money in hand, and invested money keeps earning, so the fair figures are $909,604 and 83 years 2 months.

Show Work

Enter your pension details to see the step-by-step working.

Formulas

Pension formula
A = multiplier × years × final average salary
The yearly pension; paid as A ÷ 12 a month
With a COLA
Ay = A × (1 + c)y
The pension in year y of retirement
Value at retirement
PV = Σ (Ay ÷ 12) × a₁₂ ÷ (1 + d)y
a₁₂ = (1 − (1 + i)−12) ÷ i, with i = (1 + d)1/12 − 1, values one year of monthly payments
Invested lump sum
Lm+1 = Lm(1 + i) − Ay/12
Month by month; the break-even age is when L reaches zero
Replacement ratio
R = A ÷ final average salary
The share of your pay the pension replaces

The Rise and Retreat of the Workplace Pension

The American Express Company set up one of the first private pension plans in the United States in 1875, for older workers who could no longer do the heavy work of moving freight. Railroads, utilities and governments followed, and after the Second World War a pension became a standard part of a good job, built on the same formula this calculator uses: a slice of your salary for every year you worked.

Failures such as the closure of the Studebaker car plant in 1963, which left thousands of workers with little of the pension they were promised, led to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. It set funding and vesting rules and created the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation to insure private plans.

Since then many private employers have frozen their pensions or offered lump sums to buy them out, and most pensions today are in the public sector. A lump-sum offer is a one-way choice, which is why it pays to value both options carefully.

About This Tool

This calculator applies the standard defined-benefit formula, then puts a value on the pension by discounting every monthly payment, with a yearly COLA if your plan has one, back to the age it starts. With a lump-sum offer it compares the two and finds the break-even age, both the simple one and the fairer one where the lump sum keeps earning. It values payments only for your lifetime: survivor options, taxes and the safety of the plan are not included, and real plans calculate lump sums with their own interest and mortality rules.

Everything runs in your browser; nothing you enter is sent anywhere. Estimates for planning and education — not financial, tax or legal advice.

Related tools: Retirement Calculator, Social Security Calculator, and Annuity Calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is a defined-benefit pension worked out?

Most plans multiply three numbers: the multiplier, your years of service and your final average salary (often the average of your best three or five years). 2% × 30 years × $80,000 = $48,000 a year, or $4,000 a month, which replaces 60% of that salary. Check your plan for early-retirement reductions and caps.

Should I take the lump sum or the monthly pension?

Compare the offer with what the payments are worth today. A $48,000 pension with a 2% COLA, paid from 62 to 90 and discounted at 5%, is worth $909,604, so a $750,000 offer is $159,604 short. Invested at 5% and paying yourself the same income, the $750,000 runs out at 83 years 2 months. If you expect to live past that, the pension is worth more.

What discount rate should I use?

Use the return you could realistically earn on the lump sum with similar safety. The choice moves the answer a lot: the same pension is worth $1,024,902 at 4% and $812,815 at 6%. A higher rate makes a lump sum look better, because you assume you can grow it faster yourself.

How much is a cost-of-living adjustment worth?

A lot over a long retirement. Without a COLA the $48,000 pension above is worth $731,354 at 5%, so the $750,000 offer would be $18,646 better. With a 2% COLA the pension grows to $81,931 a year by 89 and is worth $909,604. Check whether your COLA is guaranteed or granted year by year.

What is the break-even age?

The age at which taking the lump sum stops paying off. This calculator invests the lump sum at your discount rate and pays out the same income; the age it runs dry is the break-even. Not counting any interest, $750,000 is paid back by 75 years 9 months, but because invested money keeps earning, the fair comparison is 83 years 2 months.

How do I use the Pension Calculator: Lump Sum or Annuity?

Just type your numbers. The answer shows up right away — there is no button to press. Change anything and it updates by itself.

Is it free? Does it work without internet?

Yes to both. It is free with no sign-up, and once the page has loaded it keeps working even with no internet.

Where does my data go?

Nowhere — every calculation runs on your own device. Nothing you enter is uploaded, logged, or stored.

Common Use Cases

A lump-sum offer

A $39,375 pension from 65 is worth $541,359 at 5.5% to 90, so a $600,000 offer is $58,641 more and lasts until 96 years 10 months.

Checking an annual statement

1.5% × 20 years × $70,000 is $21,000 a year, $1,750 a month, worth $302,696 at 5% from 65 to 90.

A long career

2.5% × 35 years × $100,000 = $87,500 a year, 87.5% of salary; with a 2% COLA that is worth $1,925,921 at 60.

Retiring early

2% × 28 years × $75,000 from age 55 is $3,500 a month; a 1.5% COLA makes it $69,678 a year by 89.

Comparing job offers

Put a value on a pension when one job offers it and another pays more: $48,000 a year from 62 is worth $909,604 at a 5% rate.

Last updated: