Construction

Fastener Materials Guide

Bolt and screw materials compared by minimum strength and corrosion resistance: carbon and alloy steel grades, stainless A2 (304) and A4 (316), brass and copper alloys, aluminium, titanium, coatings and galvanic corrosion.

Alloy steel is by far the strongest common fastener material: Grade 8 and class 10.9 bolts have a minimum tensile strength of about 1034-1040 MPa (150 ksi) and class 12.9 reaches 1220 MPa, against 700 MPa for A2-70 / A4-70 stainless, 290-370 MPa for brass and 280-510 MPa for aluminium screws. Stainless trades strength for corrosion resistance: A2 (304 type) for indoor and inland use, A4 (316 type, with molybdenum) under water and on the coast (Bossard). Below, every figure is a specification minimum or a maker's published value with its source: steel and stainless from Portland Bolt's and Bossard's copies of SAE J429, ISO 898-1 and ISO 3506; non-ferrous screws, coatings and corrosion from Bossard's technical handbook; temperature limits and the galvanic series from NASA's Fastener Design Manual. For head markings see Bolt Grade Markings; for tightening, the Bolt Torque & Preload Calculator.

Carbon and alloy steel grades

Grade (diameter)Tensile min. (MPa)Yield min. (MPa)Head marking
SAE J429 Grade 2 (1/4 - 3/4 in)510 (74 ksi)393 (57 ksi)No grade mark
SAE J429 Grade 2 (7/8 - 1-1/2 in)414 (60 ksi)248 (36 ksi)No grade mark
SAE J429 Grade 5 (1/4 - 1 in)827 (120 ksi)634 (92 ksi)3 radial lines, 120° apart
SAE J429 Grade 5 (1-1/8 - 1-1/2 in)724 (105 ksi)558 (81 ksi)3 radial lines, 120° apart
SAE J429 Grade 8 (1/4 - 1-1/2 in)1034 (150 ksi)896 (130 ksi)6 radial lines, 60° apart
ISO 898-1 class 4.6400 (58 ksi)240 (35 ksi)"4.6" on the head
ISO 898-1 class 8.8 (d ≤ 16 mm)800 (116 ksi)640 (93 ksi)"8.8" on the head
ISO 898-1 class 8.8 (d > 16 mm)830 (120 ksi)660 (96 ksi)"8.8" on the head
ISO 898-1 class 10.91040 (151 ksi)940 (136 ksi)"10.9" on the head
ISO 898-1 class 12.91220 (177 ksi)1100 (160 ksi)"12.9" on the head

Steel notes

  • Plain carbon steel hardware-store bolts are typically about 55 ksi (380 MPa) ultimate and usually zinc plated; alloy steel can be heat treated up to 300 ksi but needs a coating against corrosion (NASA RP-1228).
  • Carbon and alloy steel bolts become brittle below −65 °F (−54 °C), and for plated bolts the plating usually sets the maximum service temperature (NASA RP-1228).
  • NASA advises using more fasteners of ordinary strength rather than a few above 180 ksi, which bring brittleness, critical-flaw and quality-control problems.
  • Full grade-by-grade proof, yield and tensile values, including ASTM structural grades, are on Bolt Grade Markings. MPa / ksi conversions in this table are rounded (1 ksi = 6.8948 MPa).

Stainless steel groups (ISO 3506)

Steel groupExample material no.Cr / Ni / Mo (%)Bossard's guidance
A11.430517-19 / 8-10 / —Free-machining (sulphur added); less corrosion resistant than A2.
A2 (304 type, "18-8")1.430117.5-19.5 / 8-10.5 / —Standard quality: above water, inland climate.
A4 (316 type)1.440116.5-18.5 / 10-13 / 2-2.5Under water, coastal climate.
A81.452919-21 / 24-26 / 6-7Sea water; high resistance to stress-corrosion cracking (indoor pools).
A3, A51.4541, 1.4571as A2, A4 + Ti or NbStabilised against intergranular corrosion after welding or heating.

Stainless steel strength classes (austenitic, ISO 3506)

Property classSteel gradesTensile Rm min. (MPa)0.2% proof Rp0.2 min. (MPa)Elongation after fracture (mm)
50A1, A2, A3, A4, A5 (not A8)5002100.6 d
70A1-A5, A87004500.4 d
80A1-A5, A88006000.3 d
100A4, A5, A8 only10008000.2 d

Stainless notes

  • Over 97% of stainless fasteners are austenitic and A2 and A4 are the standard grades; the commercial quality is class 70 (Bossard). Unmarked stainless parts "often only correspond to property classes A2-50 or A4-50".
  • "18-8" means about 18% chromium and 8% nickel; it is not a specification, and an 18-8 bolt is not necessarily certified type 304. Type 316 lowers chromium to about 16%, raises nickel to about 10% and adds 2% molybdenum for better chloride resistance (Portland Bolt).
  • Austenitic stainless is non-magnetic when annealed, but cold heading and thread rolling turn some of it martensitic, so finished 304 and 316 bolts are often slightly magnetic (Portland Bolt).
  • Stainless threads gall (cold-weld) under load; lubricate or wax them, which also changes the tightening torque (Portland Bolt). Inch stainless bolts to ASTM F593 run from 65-85 ksi tensile (as-formed) to 100-150 ksi (cold-worked, up to 5/8 in).
  • Stainless needs oxygen to keep its protective oxide layer: crevices, standing water, dirt and coatings that shut out air can make even A4 corrode, and chlorides can cause sudden stress-corrosion cracking (Bossard).

Copper-alloy, aluminium and plastic screws

Material (ISO 8839 class)Rp0.2 min. (MPa)Rm min. (MPa)Density (g/cm³)
Copper E-Cu58 / OF-Cu (Cu1)150-320200-3508.94
Brass CuZn37 (Cu2)250290-3708.44
Free-cutting brass CuZn39Pb3 (Cu3)250370—
Tin bronze CuSn6 (Cu4)200400—
Copper-nickel-silicon CuNi1Si (Cu5)540590—
Aluminium bronze CuAl10Ni5Fe4 (Cu7)270640—
Aluminium AlMg5, EN AW-5019 (AL2)200280-3102.8
Aluminium AlSi1MgMn, 6082 T6 (AL3)2503102.8
Aluminium AlCu4MgSi, 2017 T6 (AL4)2904202.8
Aluminium AlZn5.5MgCu, 7075 T73 (AL6)4405102.8
Polyamide PA 6 / PA 66—70-85 / 77-841.13 / 1.14

Non-ferrous uses, titanium and nickel alloys

  • Uses Bossard gives for the screws above: copper (Cu1) where high electrical conductivity is needed; brass (Cu2) for normal fastenings; CuNi1Si (Cu5) as seawater resistant; AlMg5 (AL2) for very good corrosion and seawater resistance at low strength; 6082 (AL3) for very good corrosion resistance at medium strength; 2017 (AL4) and 7075 (AL6) for high strength but the lowest corrosion resistance, 2017 being prone to stress-corrosion cracking because of its copper content. Polyamide tensile values are from Bossard's thermoplastics table.
  • Titanium fasteners reach up to 160 ksi (1100 MPa) ultimate, are usable from −350 to +500 °F (NASA RP-1228, Table I) and see limited use outside aerospace. Bossard lists commercially pure grades 1-4 for "excellent resistance to corrosion in oxidising media which contain chloride" (chemical plant, desalination, medical), grade 5 alloy for high specific strength (aerospace, vehicles, fasteners) and palladium grades 7 and 11 for moist chloride media. No grade-by-grade fastener strengths were found in the sources used, so none are given.
  • Nickel-copper (Monel 400 / K-500): high strength and toughness over a wide temperature range and excellent resistance to salt water and many acids and alkalis (Bossard).
  • A-286 stainless is usable from −423 to +1200 °F, is usually made up to 160 ksi (220 ksi on special order) and is not susceptible to stress corrosion, which makes it NASA's preferred aerospace stainless; 17-4PH and 17-7PH reach 180-220 ksi but are susceptible to stress corrosion (NASA RP-1228).

Zinc and zinc-alloy coatings (ISO 4042)

Coating systemNominal thickness (µm)Salt spray to white rust (h)Salt spray to red rust (h)Cr(VI)-free
Zn, transparent / blue passivated5 / 88 / 848 / 72yes
Zn, thick-layer passivated5 / 872 / 72120 / 192yes
Zn, thick-layer passivated + sealed5 / 8120 / 120168 / 240yes
Zn, black chromated5 / 812 / 24— / 72no
ZnNi, iridescent passivated5 / 8120 / 120480 / 720yes

Coating notes

  • Hours are Bossard's minimum neutral salt spray (ISO 9227) results for barrel-plated parts as coated, before handling, sorting or transport damage. They compare coatings; they are not a service life.
  • Hydrogen embrittlement: electroplated fasteners under tension with hardness of 360 HV or more risk delayed fracture; baking reduces but does not remove the risk. For safety-critical parts Bossard recommends inorganic zinc-flake coating, mechanical plating or stainless instead.
  • Temperature limits (NASA RP-1228, Table II): zinc useful to about 250 °F (its corrosion protection degrades above 140 °F); cadmium 450 °F (the most common aerospace plating in 1990); nickel 1100 °F. Black oxide with oil "does little more than enhance the appearance"; the oil film is its only corrosion protection.
  • Zinc is sacrificial: it protects scratched areas by corroding first. Hot-dip galvanizing is the thick zinc process; galvanized threads need oversize tapping or an undercut bolt thread (ISO 10684, Bossard).

Galvanic corrosion: which metals to keep apart

  • NASA's galvanic ranking (abridged), most active (corrodes) first: magnesium, zinc, aluminium 5056 / 5052 / 1100, cadmium, aluminium 2024 / 7075, mild steel, cast iron, 410 and 304 / 316 stainless (active), lead, tin, Muntz metal, nickel, Inconel, brasses, copper, silicon bronze, copper-nickel, nickel and Inconel (passive), titanium, Monel, 304 and 316 stainless (passive), silver, graphite, gold (least active). The farther apart two metals are, the faster the more active one corrodes in moisture.
  • The anode (more active metal) should be the larger part: stainless fasteners in a carbon-steel assembly are acceptable, carbon-steel fasteners in a stainless or copper assembly are poor practice (NASA).
  • Magnesium must be completely insulated from fasteners (e.g. zinc chromate primer); cadmium- or zinc-plated fasteners are the least harmful if the insulation is damaged (NASA).
  • Passivated stainless (oxide film formed by acid or furnace treatment) is far less active than unpassivated stainless, which is why 304 and 316 appear twice in the list.

Corrections to the previous version

  • Stainless 304 "515 MPa", 316 "515 MPa" and 316L "485 MPa" were sheet or bar values with no source; fastener values are now the ISO 3506 classes (A2-70 / A4-70: 700 MPa tensile, 450 MPa proof) and ASTM F593.
  • "SAE 9, 180 ksi" removed: it is not an SAE J429 grade and no source was found. "Metric 4.6 equivalent to SAE 2" changed to Portland Bolt's rough equivalent, ASTM A307 Grade A. Grade 8 tensile 1 040 MPa → 1034 MPa (150 ksi).
  • Removed as unsourced: "Grade 8 fasteners are brittle, prefer grade 5 for shock", "titanium: strength-to-weight king", the cost column, and "aluminium + steel screws fail fast outdoors" (replaced by NASA's galvanic series and rule).
  • Added: copper-alloy and aluminium screw strengths, titanium and nickel alloys, ISO 4042 zinc coating performance, hydrogen embrittlement, temperature limits.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is A2 or A4 stainless better for bolts outdoors?

Bossard's rule of thumb is A2 (the 304 type) above water and in an inland climate, A4 (the 316 type, with 2-2.5% molybdenum) under water and in a coastal climate, and the 6% molybdenum A8 grade for sea water and stress-corrosion risks such as indoor pools. Portland Bolt likewise calls 316 the preferred material for marine construction because molybdenum improves resistance to chlorides.

Are stainless steel bolts as strong as Grade 8?

No. Standard A2-70 and A4-70 stainless bolts have a minimum tensile strength of 700 MPa and 0.2% proof strength of 450 MPa; Grade 8 has 1034 MPa (150 ksi) tensile and 896 MPa (130 ksi) yield. Inch stainless to ASTM F593 is 65-150 ksi tensile depending on condition. Even the strongest common stainless grade is "not close to the strength of alloy grade 8 bolts" (Portland Bolt).

How strong are brass and aluminium bolts?

Bossard lists brass screws (CuZn37) at 250 MPa 0.2% proof and 290-370 MPa tensile, about a third to half of a class 8.8 steel bolt. Aluminium screws range from 280-310 MPa tensile (AlMg5, very good corrosion resistance) to 510 MPa (7075 T73, high strength but the lowest corrosion resistance), at about 2.8 g/cm³, roughly a third of the density of steel.

Can you use stainless screws in aluminium or carbon steel?

In a wet joint the more active metal corrodes, so it should be the larger part. NASA's Fastener Design Manual says stainless fasteners can be used in carbon-steel assemblies, because the large carbon-steel mass is the anode, but carbon-steel fasteners in a stainless or copper assembly are poor practice. Aluminium sits well above stainless in the galvanic series, so isolate the parts or seal the joint against moisture.

Does zinc plating cause hydrogen embrittlement?

It can on hard bolts. Bossard (per ISO 4042) warns of hydrogen-embrittlement failures in electroplated fasteners under tension with a hardness of 360 HV or more; baking reduces but cannot remove the risk, so for safety-critical parts it recommends non-electrolytic zinc flake, mechanical plating or stainless. Class 12.9 (385-435 HV) is always above that hardness; class 10.9 (320-380 HV) can be.

Was this article helpful?